Magic Eraser Extra Durable, 4.6 x 2.4, 0.7" Thick, 4/Box

I love this product. It cleans scuff marks from virtually everything you can think of, and removes dirt from scratch marks on counter tops and floors. Cleans up walls without removing the paint. Only thing i don't care for is that it falls apart as your using it. I go threw many in my house every month.

I really love this product. It crumbles pretty quickly but is strong enough to get even the oldest baked-by-the-sun grime off my plastic patio chairs.

I bought Mr. Clean Magic Eraser Extra Power based on a positive review of your product. I am very disappointed in the product. It literally fell apart in my hands while I was using it. I will tell you that it worked for two rinsings, but after that, nothing. I ended up using your Mr. Clean liquid product with a different household sponge and it worked fine, except I had to go over it twice.
I will not use your product - Mr. Clean Magic Eraser again and I will tell my sister about my negative experience, as well.
You might want to think about resolving this issue and making the sponge just a little bit denser/tougher, so it doesn't fall apart.

I walk away from my 3 year old for two minutes and she has scribbled permanent marker all over our hardwood floors, chairs, and wood cabinets. It stretched Up to 3 feet in some areas. I felt doom come over me and started seeing dollar signs flashing before my eyes... Thank goodness I bought a 4 pack a couple days ago! I was able to get all of it out!!! Thank you Mr. clean!

My husband and I bought a house last year. We wanted to deep clean the house before we moved in. I made sure that we had some Mr. Clean Magic Erasers before we got started, and I was very glad that I did! The people before us obviously had a way different meaning of the word "clean" than we did! We were able to use the Mister Clean Magic Erasers to get our house very clean smelling great. We love using the Mister Clean Magic Erasers now to clean up the messes our toddler makes!

Tried these new erasers on several surfaces and they always fell apart. even washing up a florr stain it disintergrated. Used to rub surface dirt on upholstery and some dirt came off but I had to vacuum up the eraser mess. Will look for old erasers. These new ones are used once an need to be thrown away or use broken up pieces.

I use these all the time to clean everything from car wheels to cabinets to toys left outdoors. Love them!!

The 50% stronger used to be be dense and worked well on dirty surfaces, but no more! They crumble and fall apart in chunks while using. They do not melt away they break up. Especially, if you are cleaning a greasy surface. And forget cleaning outdoor furniture or car tires! You cannot advertise that anymore. Go back to making these the way they were made when first introduced.

ROBERTSON CLARK stencil restoration
The dalkeith Historical society are property owners since august 2012 of a building that dates back to 1867. The building started out as a General Store and Post Office. then for about 100 years it was a chapel. Sometime between 1937 & 1955 an extensive stencilling network was applied to the walls and ceiling.. at some later point the walls and ceiling were covered with panelling & foam tile.It was a pleasant surprise to the Dalkeith Historical Society to find this stencil network when panelling was removed. Mr. Clean is a dry nontoxic environmentally friendly product and although expensive to use on such a large area(the eraser simply disintegrates with use and needs to be constantly replaced) does the trick . Thank you Mr. Clean

Magic Eraser did a great job of removing scuffs from my walls. Unfortunately it also took off the paint, and I now have obvious swipe marks where paint is missing. I would have preferred to keep the scuffs.

I've been such a fan of the Magic Eraser since it first came out, my friends tease me about my gushing. That is not the case for "Extra Durable". Pick a different type unless you want it crumbling into the tub or bottom of the shower. I clean weekly for 2 people as well as have 4 kids, so i do know what they normally last for. I brought 2 ME thinking I could do 3 bathrooms for a friend w those. I am now done w a full tub/shower bathroom & a shower stall bathroom and ended up w mess of the ME crumbles at the bottom of each! Not to mention that it's left me hanging for the 3rd bathroom. Magic Eraser is a fantastic product---the Extra Durable is a false advertisement, though.

Thank you sooooooo much for this product! I thought that I would have to paint the walls because of a scuff mark. I purchased this product and gave it a try....I was in shock how easily it removed the marks; now I won't have to paint the walls or door!!!!

Can't even finish a product, without this breaking up, preventing cleanup. They use to be a lot better, but guess not now. Must be using different materials to do this! I am not a happy campaign, where as they cost a lot!

Used the magic eraser just to get a general wipe and clean on the inside of my car (dash door handles etc) and it crumbled everywhere and left a dirt smear all over everything once it dried. I had to vacuum and clean the entire inside of my car for a second time. Not going to be purchased again for sure!

This product works great! Have used it for many years. I was wondering if they can be used in other ways not listed. For instance, could they be used to scrub dirt and wax from fruits and veggies? For instance, apples, Potatoes, Mushrooms, cucumbers, etc. Just a thought. I thought I would try, but I was wondering how it would affect it.

Permanent marker on walls comes off with almost no effort cleaned stove n cupboard fronts. Only problem it got ruined and I don't have another and I was on a roll... I will definitely try these again.

I totally love these Magic Erasers. They make cleaning fun! My favorite thing is no harsh chemicals.

The extra durable magic erasers disintegrate breaking into a horrible mess of small pieces shortly after you begin to use them. What an awful product. What happened to your quality control? Have you tried using your own product?

These work great on the plastic lawn chairs, I try to stock up for summer every year.

I've always kept a few of these around the house but I recently watched a video where artists are using these to lift watercolors off their paper to correct mistakes or add in elements. I tried this and was amazed at how well it works. I may never be a well know watercolor painter but at least now I can fix a mistake and not have to start a new sheet. Thanks Mr. Clean!

Our house was flooded in September of 2018. It took 3 months to get things back to “livable”. It was at least 2 months after the flood when we tackled cleaning the inside of the garage door. It had a nasty stain from dirty flood water. We tried outdoor cleaner with bleach in it to no avail. I suggested we try the Magic Eraser and it was amazing! All of the 2 month old stain cane off and the garage door looks like new! We have used it for many more cleaning jobs over the last 3 months and it has worked every time!

I first bought this product in 2003 or 2004. I love it. It to magic marker my 3 years put on an antique chest. Magic Eraser saved the day back then. Now in 2019, it doesn't work anymore. Try to remove hair dye that splatter on the wall, it did nothing but make it shine. So disappointed. The formula to make thes bars must have changed over the years. . I'll never buy another (3pk) again. Wasted money.

great clean ,work as well you would think it would.gets the scuff marks off

These shredded before I got halfway thru cleaning my bathtub. Very disappointed!

It makes me feel very powerful. It makes me feel very powerful. It makes me feel very powerful. It makes me feel very powerful. It makes me feel very powerful. It makes me feel very powerful. It makes me feel very powerful. It makes me feel very powerful. It makes me feel very powerful.

Nice product..................,..... Great product

All Magic Eraser products serve a purpose. They remove mineral deposits, soap scum, baked on grease, scuff marks, and most any stubborn spot that other products will not. They do not last. They crumble and disintegrate quickly. An eraser, even the extra durable has a less that 50% chance of making it through one cleaning of the master bath. Two six-foot sink/counter tops, one large tub, and a 2.5 ft by 3.5 ft glassed shower. Does not remove or prevent mildew as a bleach based product would. I keep a supply in the house because they do serve a purpose. There are no other products like it. Lack of durability makes it an expensive purchase. The kitchen eraser with the blue foam center is one of the product line I will not purchase again. There's no benefit over the other styles that I can see. I recommend the product for its ability to clean. However, buyers need to understand that it is not a long-term use product.

I was not impressed at all with the mr. Clean magic erasers. I had scribes maybe twice and it ripped apart and left white flecks all over the surface. Definitely not worth it and I will not be purchasing any more

I purchased the original erasers, they fell apart FAST !! So l decided to purchase the DURABLE , thinking they would be more effective, NOPE !! They started falling apart and left white pieces all over the place, that I clean up in addition. How is it possible to get something clean, when you are picking up the broken pieces of your cleaning product, before you can get it cleaned ? EXTRA WORK!! I AM AWARE THAT THERE WILL BE A COMPUTERIZED RESPONSE TO THIS AND I SHOULD CALL, BUT WHAT IS A CUSTOMER SERVICE AGENT GOING TO DO, TO CLEAN MY BATHROOM, KITCHEN, ETC ? Clean it for me?

I had grease smears on my fishing/safari jacket. I used Mr. Clean Magic Erasers and it took all the grease out, left no "halo" and took less than 2 minutes! I have used it for ages, and it is great, but who would have thought it worked on fabric?!

The magic eraser works wonders on everything from floors to walls from sinks to appliances. It is my saving grace.

Cuts through grease and grime but not as durable as it says. Starts coming apart.